September Newsletter

“The Official Community Plan Update”       

September 16, 2023

In this newsletter, I want to summarise discussions about the “redo” of Victoria’s Official Community Plan (OCP). As mentioned in my August Newsletter, public input to the current 10-year OCP Update has been significantly reduced – and I find this troublesome.

(Relevant documents and Council meeting e-links are provided in Appendix: Links and Quotes)

The Existing OCP:

The Official Community Plan was forwarded for adoption in the spring of 2012. The OCP has the highest legal status in the hierarchy of City plans and is adopted as a City bylaw. Under the BC Local Government Act, the OCP provides a framework of objectives and policies to guide decisions on planning and land use management. While community well-being and environmental considerations were considered “optional”, the City opted for an OCP that was broader in scope and included items such as food security and emergency management.

Victoria’s 2012 OCP was adopted following two and a half years of public consultation. Many OCP amendments were made during the ensuing years with a final “Refresh” amendment on September 7, 2023, to align the OCP with the policies created from 2018 through 2020.

The 10-year OCP Update – Review and Revision Timeline (See Appendix: Compressed Timeline):

OCPs typically take 3-4 years to plan and complete. However, staff recommended a compressed timeline of about 22 months of work over a 30 month period for the 10-year OCP Update, acknowledging reduced opportunities for public input.

Some Councillors proposed even less consultation, with a 16 month timeline – the 2022 election result was cited as sufficient public input to justify this further reduction. Council directed staff to develop another plan with an abbreviated time-line.

In May, staff returned to Council with a further reduced timeline which further limited public input. The revised timeline proposes finishing in Q2 2025 rather than Q4 2025. This represents a 20% reduction from the originally proposed timeline that was already comparatively ambitious. Much of the time “saved” was taken from public input opportunity. Rather than using discussions to seek public input over 7+ months followed later with a 3 month consultation on draft directions, the reduced timeline offers one 4 month citywide engagement period on draft directions.

The final vote on this reduced timeline with significantly less opportunity for public input was 7-2 with Councillor Coleman and myself in opposition.

The 10-year OCP Update Approach:

Staff identified changes in process that would facilitate the revision in the reduced timeline including rescinding the local area planning (LAP) direction. This leaves Oaklands, the Jubilees and James Bay at a disadvantage as the city-wide approach does not allow for the community-led neighbourhood-based components to the planning process that were developed in other parts of the city.

Direction in planning documents: “This OCP 10-year Update will seek to create one citywide plan to foster an equitable, nimble Victoria that can meaningfully confront the housing crisis and increase our resilience to climate change . . . A citywide approach, focused on diversity and targeted conversations, strives for genuine engagement and equitable empowerment in planning for Victoria’s future, while balancing the need for immediate housing and climate action . . . While the process will include direct and targeted engagement with diverse stakeholders, such as non-profit housing organizations, local builders and developers, adjacent municipalities, the Greater Victoria School District, BC Transit, advocacy groups, and diverse community groups and organizations.”

Staff have not yet finalised a stakeholder list for the early outreach identified in the abbreviated timeline chart. This early outreach will focus on community-serving groups. As the process advances, the stakeholder groups will be broader.

Staff began their work on the preparation and technical work in June. Several tools will be used in the engagement approach. The engagement plans will soon be completed as the “early process communications” is to begin in early October. In-person events as well as print and digital advertising or mailouts may be used to reach people. Word-of-mouth will help spread the word about opportunities to participate.

Working groups formed for past work on Local Area Plans, which usually had some members from neighbourhood land use groups, were considered to not always reflect the city’s diversity. Hence, the city’s equity policy will guide selection of the “right” people to form any OCP Update working group.

Staff understand that the tight timeline may require the process to remain somewhat nimble. The staff report states “While targeting a public hearing after one phase of engagement, if any concerns or complications arise, the City may opt, with Council direction, to revise the approach prior to public hearing.”

I will continue to work on your behalf to ensure that you have a voice in the future of our city.

Please make your voice heard, become familiar with the current OCP, be prepared to participate in the months ahead. Consultation will be completed in the first part of 2024.

There are several topics which I hope to explore in the weeks ahead including the City Council response to the MNP Governance Review Report (including remuneration) and a few comments on the upcoming 2024 budget.

Regards,

Marg

For those wanting to learn more about Councillor positions on matters, video links are in the “Links and Quotes” Appendix.

Appendix: Compressed Time-line

Notes:
• Revised May 11, 2023, timeline proposes finishing in Q2 2025 rather than Q4 2025.
• Represents a further 20% reduction from usual timeline for OCP development.
• Originally proposed timeline of April 13, 2023, was already comparatively ambitious.

April 13, 2023

May 11, 2023

Appendix: Links and Quotes

Note: Items considered at Council may be on one or several agendas over a few month period. Typically, staff present to Council at a Committee of the Whole. If Council believes the proposal is ready for staff to proceed, the matter is forwarded by vote, to an upcoming Council meeting for confirmation. This Council meeting is usually in the daytime and directly follows the Committee of the Whole Meeting or follows a few weeks later.

The date/link to the meeting which details issues has been bolded.

Official Community Plan (OCP):

OCP and Zoning Amendments Refresh to clarify and align changes over past years to the OCP:

OCP document July 2012, updated September 7, 2023.

February 23 Committee of the Whole (item G-1):
Starts at video 1:35 hour to 2:22 hour

September 7 Council following Committee of the Whole: – Third Reading
Starts at video 7:08 minutes to 9:00 minutes

OCP 10 year review:
April 13 Committee of the Whole (item G7):
OCP Discussion at video 2:47 hour to 4:31 hour with Q/A starting at 3:09
Staff presentation and report 90 minutes of Councillor Q/A

April 27 Council following Committee of the Whole (item G1aa):
5:10 minutes to 6:00 minutes– endorsing approach to OCP 10 year review going forward as per April 13

May 11 Committee of the Whole (item F3):
OCP Discussion at video 4:57 hour to 1:22:37 hour with Q/A starting at 18:17

May 11 Council to follow Committee of the Whole (item G1ca)
3:44 minutes to 4:13 minutes . . . Councillors Gardiner/Coleman opposed due to further reduction in engagement

Campaign Volunteers would assist with:

  • Administrative work such as handling and distributing promotional materials
  • Accompanying me on door-to-door visits
  • Assisting at all-candidates gatherings
  • Scheduling

How would you like to help the campaign?

Things to know about donations:

  • Donations are NOT tax deductible
  • Cannot be made by corporations, unions or other entities
  • Maximum contribution per candidate campaign is $1,250
  • A donor must:
    • be a resident of B.C.
    • be a Canadian citizen or permanent resident
    • provide full name and residential address
  • Each campaign must register all donations/donors
  • Anonymous donations of more than $50 are not permitted
  • The names of donors contributing $100 or more will be reported publicly following the election. Supporters often choose to donate $99; names of these donors are not published

If you prefer to donate by cheque please make it payable to “Marg Gardiner Campaign” and email me to arrange collection.